Okay, well I will be the first to admit CO2 is pretty awesome and I completely understand why you feel the ways you do... so I will tell you something I wouldn't normally... If you are going to stick to using CO2, depending on the size of your growing area look at CO2 bottles for smaller areas and CO2 generators for larger areas. I did a little price surfing for a friend last year, and found a used CO2 tank on Craigslist for $50, but a new one was only $108 and since they need to be tested every 5-years to see if the tank is still good or if you have to replace it, seriously buy DOT Approved and by NEW. If you buy a tank and it doesn't meet DOT Approval nobody will fill your tank and once they find it doesn't meet specs they won't give it back to you either in some places because it is a serious safety issue, I've seen this issue happen before when a tank has been pulled for random inspection.
So the CO2 50# tank will set you back $108, a CO2 Regulator will set you back another $100-$120, to fill the CO2 tank should run about $25-$35 and then I personally love to tell new growers to check out the DEC-4 by Sentinel as their environmental controller. The DEC-4 will handle the Cooling - Heating - Humidity and CO2 (set to come on at 1100-ppm and off at 1300-ppm) and costs $280. I looked at a few CO2 controllers, that don't do anything else for just $200+... so to get one that does it all for $280, with a 5-year warranty when most others say 1-3 years... Oh and the DEC-4 on its CO2 setting has Day Free, the CO2 is active as long as its daylight, Day Lock the controller keeps CO2 levels 1100-1300 and Night the setting on it for those mushroom growers who struggle to find a night CO2 controller. Well you get the idea why some things just stick in your mind. I mean you can do your own math and see which setup will be most cost effective for you, but the CO2 tanks and CO2 generators are the cheapest long term, just make sure you set it up to be airtight to run CO2 like this. Hope this helps.